Back
Samo@samo

Wish You Were Here

Pink Floyd · 1975
10.0/10
hot take · room says 7.01 spinListened September 17, 2024

Phenomenal

At this point Pink Floyd was cooking. Coming off of their best album so far and huge commercial hit. They went a pretty different direction with this one and yet it's still fantastic! Feeling like a pretty Gilmour driven album, between the 25 minutes of Shine On and Wish You Were Here, but the lyrics are very much mostly Roger of course. And some of his best. It's a very smooth listen.

Only 5 songs compared to the 10 on the previous album. Some might argue that this one is even better though. I find it difficult to choose but I would probably just lean toward Dark Side. Have A Cigar is great, the title track is great, and Welcome to the Machine is great. And they're all sandwiched in the middle of the real showstopper which is Shine On You Crazy Diamond. Such a good song.

It's fun that this album contains the only Pink Floyd song that wasn't vocally performed by a member of the band (Other than Great Gig) which is Have A Cigar.

Overall incredible album. How did they put out two masterpieces in a row? Surely they can't keep this up?!

Share this card

Pressing your card…

Everyone's logsupdated Sep 17, 2024 · imported from Musicboard

Replies

    Sign in to reply.

    More from Samo

    Their diary

    Keyboard shortcuts

    /
    Search (or Ctrl K)
    g then f
    Feed
    g then d
    Discover
    g then c
    Charts
    g then b
    Listening clubs
    ?
    This list